Wednesday, March 2, 2011

GWT and GXT

Recently I've been doing a lot of development in GWT. I have to say that, despite being a big fan of pure JavaScript RIA, I'm liking GWT a lot. It has been a couple of years since I touched GWT and it has come a long way. I particularly like the Activities and Places API, although there's a bit of a learning curve there.

One thing I don't particularly like though is Sencha's EXT-GWT, or GXT as it is known. For those that don't know, GXT provides an abundance of widgets including a fully featured Grid. This is of course highly enticing, but what I've found is that GXT appears to be an all-or-nothing proposition. GXT is more akin to a framework than a toolkit because it effects how you lay out your code. What isn't clear to me is why it has its own layout architecture and its own event architecture. That's just confusing!

I'm starting to think that GXT plugged a few gaps in GWT 1.x and is becoming increasing less relevant. GWT 2.x deprecates a lot of GXT; even GWT 1.6 introduced a new event model.

Don't even get me started on GXT's Grid separation of concerns; its one of those widgets that likes to influence how the data transfer objects look. Plain wrong. The whole loader concept is terribly confusing as well.

I feel that if GWT's TableCell was as fully featured as GXT's Grid then no one would probably use GXT.

Perhaps I'm being a little harsh though. GXT widgets present nicely. It is just that they don't just "slot in"; you've got to buy into all of GXT to use a little of it.

2 comments:

Andrew said...

Articles are created to express different body of knowledge. That is why I admire writers who are passionate of doing such incredible job. I salute you guys. By the way, I like you post for it is specifically talk about current issues and technicalities in life. I look forward for your subsequent post.I look forward for your next article.Thanks Marks Liferay Blog

Farzanegan said...

I'm looking forward to GXT dying- it is not well done.